How are insurance stocks doing?
Property-casualty and life insurers. Here is how they have done as a group against the S&P 500, and which of them are leading and lagging.
Updated Oct 9, 2026
Lagging
Insurance stocks are down 7% over the past year as an equal-weighted group, against +16% for the S&P 500. 5 of 30 beat the index. Travelers Companies (TRV) leads at +30% and Kemper (KMPR) trails at −46%. Over the past month the group is −3%, against +3% for the S&P.
The past year
The group against the S&P 500, each set to $100 a year ago. Select a stock in the table to chart it against the group.
All 30 insurance stocks
Sorted by the past year’s return. Select a row to chart the stock against the group, or its ticker to open its page. Select a column to sort.
| Stock | P3 | 1M | 3M | YTD | 1Y | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TRV Travelers Companies | 69Strong | +0.3% | +8% | +27% | +30% | Bellwether |
| RNR RenaissanceRe | 62Middling | +1.5% | +3% | +18% | +26% | Distribution Top |
| AIZ Assurant | 40Middling | −5.2% | −5% | +11% | +22% | Churning Winner |
| THG Hanover Insurance | 52Middling | −2.1% | +1% | +20% | +19% | Hot Hand |
| CB Chubb | 34Middling | +0.7% | −4% | +9% | +19% | Exhausted Rally |
| ALL Allstate | 38Middling | −8.9% | −11% | +10% | +8% | Churning Winner |
| L Loews | 47Middling | −2.2% | −8% | +1% | +4% | Rolling Over |
| ACGL Arch Capital | 25Weak | −0.7% | −7% | 0% | +3% | Turning Up |
| EG Everest | 27Weak | −0.7% | −3% | +9% | +2% | Show-Me Grower |
| AFL Aflac | 55Middling | +0.1% | −7% | +4% | +2% | Wallflower |
| AXS AXIS Capital | 29Weak | −2.2% | −16% | −10% | 0% | Turning Up |
| CINF Cincinnati Financial | 20Weak | −3.7% | −11% | 0% | −1% | Show-Me Grower |
| CNA CNA Financial | 32Weak | −2.8% | −11% | −3% | −1% | Broken Year |
| HIG Hartford | 51Middling | −5.6% | −8% | −6% | −3% | Show-Me Grower |
| AFG American Financial | 26Weak | −0.4% | −2% | +3% | −4% | Falling Knife |
| WRB W. R. Berkley | 12Weak | +2.7% | −3% | +3% | −8% | Broken Year |
| AIG American International | 26Weak | +2.7% | −4% | −10% | −8% | Bottom Fished |
| MKL Markel | 29Weak | −1.2% | −10% | −18% | −10% | Broken Year |
| PGR Progressive | 42Middling | +0.6% | −7% | −5% | −11% | Turning Up |
| ORI Old Republic International | 26Weak | −6.5% | −9% | −16% | −12% | Show-Me Grower |
| MRSH Marsh McLennan | 29Weak | −0.9% | −3% | −5% | −14% | Falling Knife |
| WTW Willis Towers Watson | 34Middling | −6.1% | 0% | −10% | −14% | Show-Me Grower |
| RLI RLI | 34Middling | −7.8% | −9% | −13% | −15% | Turning Up |
| AJG Arthur J. Gallagher & | 23Weak | −4.4% | −11% | −10% | −24% | Show-Me Grower |
| AON Aon | 27Weak | −11.1% | −26% | −23% | −25% | Show-Me Grower |
| KNSL Kinsale Capital | 29Weak | −7.1% | −2% | −14% | −30% | Turning Up |
| ERIE Erie Indemnity | 21Weak | −7.6% | −10% | −23% | −32% | Broken Year |
| BRO Brown & Brown | 23Weak | −5.2% | −9% | −21% | −34% | Show-Me Grower |
| RYAN Ryan Specialty | 36Middling | −4.3% | −11% | −28% | −37% | Coiled Spring |
| KMPR Kemper | 6Weak | −0.3% | −10% | −34% | −46% | Falling Knife |
How to read this page
How it’s measured. A group of large US stocks whose prices have moved together over the past five years once the market’s own moves are taken out: the same groups as Stox’s co-movement clusters. The group is equal-weighted, so each company counts the same whatever its size, and returns are share-price changes from daily closes.
Sources. Daily prices from Financial Modeling Prep; scores and co-movement groups from Stox.
An equal-weighted group can read quite differently from a sector fund, which gives the biggest companies the most weight.
P3 is Stox’s combined score of market beat, staying power and business growth, from 0 to 100. Type is the stock’s Stox Atlas type. Both describe the past year, not what comes next.
Groups are built from how stocks trade rather than from industry labels, so a company can sit with stocks from another sector that move like it.
This page is information, not investment advice. About our data and methods ›